My laptop died some weeks ago. It was a second hand lenovo x230 that I got to replace my previous x240. I know x240 is newer than x230, but the x230 can carry 16GB of ram and is really nice to dismantle and replace parts. I think it was a great improvement.
After many years reusing old laptops or even using an eepc as my main computer I’m now looking into having a new powerful machine. I use Qubes and tend to carry my laptop around with me all the time, because of that my two main requirements on a laptop are tons of RAM and being lightweight. Looking for laptops I’ve set up as limits to have least 32GB of ram and less than 1.5kg.
There is a lot of hype now with AMD Ryzen CPUs for laptops, and with good reasons. It’s way more powerful than the counterpart Intel ones, the high end ones come with 8 cores (while Intel do 4 cores). They are pretty tempting.
But I have some few concerns about them. They don’t seem to support USB-C video output, or at least you need special customization on linux to get it work. They are not so well supported by Qubes yet. And feature of Intel integrated GPUs is GVT-g (graphics virtualization), that I might want one day to enable it in Qubes.
Because of that I have decided to look into Intel laptops, anyway in the last years my main bottleneck hasn’t being CPU but RAM.
The first laptops that caught my attention are System76, specially the Lemur Pro. System76 does have nice hardware manuals on how to replace most parts and come with coreboot and Intel ME disabled. They basically rebrand chinese laptops and many other shellers provide the same ones, for example the German company Tuxedo has the InfinityBook S 14, andI belive is the same hardware than the lemur pro.
Another interesting option are the Slimbooks, another rebrander company, this time from spain. For me is an interesting option to get a laptop from spain, I would expect to have less problems to get tech support if something break than if I get it from the US (like the System76). Slimbook has a kde laptop that is basically the same than their PorX or the Tuxedo Pulse 14.
The slimbook are nice because they have an ethernet wich the lemur pro lacks.
But their keyboard look pretty bad and the reviews around seem to agree that the keyboard is not really good. I kind of like more the lemur pro, but I’m afraid of it not being robust enough to survive many years with the hard life I give to my laptops.
An option is purism laptops, but good friends recommend to avoid them. They have lied to their customers, have questionable politics and do rely heavily on libre-washing. I decided not explore them much.
Another interesting one is the framework, but is on the making and I wanted a laptop soon. I hope they do manage to deliver all that they are promising on a upgradable, repairable laptop.
traditional laptop makers
Then I’m left with the traditional laptop makers, like lenovo, dell or hp.
The first thing I found out looking at them is that there is almost no laptop under 1.5kg with non-soldered ram. In the lenovo Thinkpads there is not a single model. Same for HP I have failed to find a single model. Dell does have at least one, the Latitude 5420. A pretty nice laptop, with two slots for ram and ethernet port. Is a bit bigger than my previous laptops but not huge and just a bit heavier.
I failed to find any interesting hp laptop, not sure if I got lost on their website or the just don’t have any laptop I might like.
Accepting the reality of soldered ram and seeing that I can go lighter than my previous laptops I end up eyeing two options:
- dell XPS
Smaller size than the x230/x240 with a bigger screen. Has a developer option with ubuntu preinstalled (not available in the spanish shop). But the only connectors are two USB-C, one microSD and a minijack. I guess I can live without ethernet, but that looks a bit too limited.
- lenovo X1
A bit bigger than the XPS 13 or my previous laptops, but lighter than any of them. With most of the connectors I would want, I just miss the ethernet. A
thinkpad keyboard, which I think I like more than the dell ones. And probably more robust than the XPS (it says is military-grade). I guess the main drawback besides the soldered ram and the lack ethernet is that is not a really cheap laptop.
the final decision
It took me several days, looking into laptops and thinking under the shower. But finally I decided to accept the lack of repairability in exchange of a light and hopefully a more robust laptop.
My pick has being the Lenovo Thinkpad X1 Carbon Gen 9. I should receive it in some weeks, I guess the chip shortage is affecting here. Let’s see how it goes then.